Mederma vs. ScarAway – Which Scar Removal is Better for You?

If you are in the market for efficient scar treatment, you know that there are so many to choose from that makes it almost impossible to see which one will give you the best results that you are looking for.

If you visit your local drugstore, the aisles are probably packed with various products that claim to erase unsightly scars in a snap. But, which product should you choose?

To make matters worse, information that you find online is often confusing, as individuals who claim to have used specific products have different opinions.

To make it easier for you, we have gathered information about the two top scar treatment products on the market today – Mederma and ScarAway. Read on to find which treatment products suit you best.

Myths and Misinformation about Scar Treatments

Scar treatment misinformation is very commented these days. In fact, most of this information is often considered myths and are merely just a waste of your time, money and effort.

For instance, many believed that vitamin E could make your scars look better, when in fact they cause skin irritations according to dermatologists. In some cases, it can even make the scar worse due to severe skin reactions.

Also, another myth about scar treatments is that scar creams must be priced high for it to work. But, this is not always the case, as there are expensive scar creams that contain less active ingredients or ingredients that offer fewer benefits in clearing scars.

You can find a whole bunch of these myths out there. Thus, it is always best to consider where you are getting your information.

Mederma vs ScarAway – What Makes Them a Cut Above The Rest?


mederma-vs-scaraway-img4

Via Realself

These two scar treatment products, Mederma and ScarAway, are both useful products and contains active ingredients that work on clearing scars efficiently.

But, what makes these two products stand out? Let us take a close look at each of them.

Mederma is an onion extract based scar cream that works on both old and new scars or skin marks that resulted from surgery, burns, stretch marks, and other forms of skin injury.

It contains the following ingredients:

  • Cepalin – Onion Extract
  • Centella Asiatica – Leaf Extract
  • Hyaluronic Acid – Hydrating Agent

According to several studies conducted about Mederma or one of its active ingredients, it has shown some benefits in various animal studies and limited human studies.

Also, a human clinical trial conducted in 2008 involving patients with surgical scars due to keratosis showed that onion extract gel has significantly improved the redness, texture, softness and overall appearance of the scars.

In another study, onion extract gel of Mederma has been found out to be safe to use and has significantly improved the appearance of scars after four weeks of daily application.

In 2007, another study on the effects of onion extract to hypertrophic and keloid scars was conducted. The study specifically focused on the redness, hardness, elevation, pain, and itching of the scars.

The researchers have concluded that onion extract has significantly improved the appearance of keloid and hypertrophic scars through multiple mechanisms. However, it was ineffective in reducing itchiness and the scar height.

 So, How about ScarAway Silicone

mederma-vs-scaraway-img5

Via medicalnewstoday.com

There are 2 types of ScarAway products that you should know:

ScarAway Silicone Scar Sheet is a self-adhesive silicone sheeting designed with patented ‘Silon’ technology. Each sheet comes with a smooth fabric on one side with silicone on the other side.

The sheets are both flexible and breathable and may be trimmed according to the size of the scar.

ScarAway Silicone Gel is formulated with a patented, self-drying and transparent silicone gel technology designed to improve the appearance of scars and prevent excessive scar formation. This scar treatment works on visible older scars and newly healed wounds as well as keloids and hypertrophic scars.

mederma-vs-scaraway-imgx



The makers of this revolutionary scar treatment claim that the use of the special sheeting will efficiently flatten, shrink, and fade hypertrophic as well as keloid scars, regardless of whether they are old or new.

It shows to be effective in various types of scars including acne scars, surgery scars, burns, medical scars, and scars due to accidents, dog bites, and insect bites.

This scar treatment has numerous benefits including skin hydration and regulation of collagen production on wounds resulting in softer and flat scars.

Also, it protects the scarred tissue from any bacterial infection and reduces itching and discomfort associated with scars.

According to many reliable studies, silicone helps improve the elasticity of the scar. Also, it also reduces scar elevation along with itchiness and pain. Ultimately, it can help prevent keloid and hypertrophic scarring.

In another study, it has been noted that topical silicone gel is safe as well as useful in treating hypertrophic and keloid scars. When combined with vitamin E, the test results were more successful compared to treating scars with silicone gel alone.

Scaraway Gel Before and After Treatment (Click to see)

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel Before and After Treatment (Click to see)

Pros and Cons of Mederma and ScarAway Treatment

In summary, here are the pros and cons of Mederma and ScarAway scar treatment products.


                 Via Amazon.com

Pros

  • check
    Comes with concentrated and advanced onion extract
  • check
    Clinically proven to improve the appearance of scars
  • check
    Easy to use and apply
  • check
    Readily available at your local drugstores
  • check
    Less noticeable when administered
  • check
    Reasonable price

Cons

  • Does not reduce itchiness
  • Ineffective in lowering scar height
  • Must be administered once daily to achieve significant improvement in scar’s appearance

ScarAway Gel vs Sheets


Via Amazon.com

Pros

  • check
    Clinically proven to be effective in improving the appearance of scars
  • check
    Easy to use and apply
  • check
    It can be tailored to fit the size of the scar
  • check
    Readily available at your local drugstores
  • check
    Less noticeable when administered
  • check
    Including silicone scar sheet & Gel product

Cons

  • Not suitable for indented scars
  • Should be worn at least 12 hours a day
  • Optimal results can take about 12 weeks to be noticeable

Via Amazon.com

Pros

  • check
    Clinically proven to be effective in improving the appearance of scars
  • check
    Easy to use and apply
  • check
    It can be tailored to fit the size of the scar
  • check
    Reduces skin itchiness, scar height and possibility of bacterial infection
  • check
    Readily available at your local drugstores

Cons

  • Expensive
  • Optimal results can take about 12 weeks to be noticeable
  • Ideal for new scars and may take a longer time to work on older scars

Which Is The Best Choice?

You can find various options when it comes to scar treatments. Thus, it is always best to do your homework to find the best one there is.

The top scar treatment products in the market, Mederma and ScarAway are noted to deliver excellent results after several applications.

Both Mederma and ScarAway scar treatment products are clinically proven to be effective in improving the appearance of scars.

While both products can work on hypertrophic and keloid scars, ScarAway has taken the lead as this product is a better option if you want to reduce scar height.

Also, ScarAway significantly reduces itchiness and redness of scars.

If you are thinking of using both products, keep in mind that you cannot use them at the same time. Instead, you can use the products alternately.

  • Jessica Kelley
     

    I am Jessica, co-founder of CareHappiness.com. We work to inspire, educate and empower our readers with all the latest updates and authentic information. Our goal is to bring up the “Healthy attitude” among people in the world. On CareHappiness.com you will find high-quality health information, fitness tips, diet charts and answer to all your health queries.

    Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments